This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Welcome to The Debrief, Box Score’s freewheeling conversation about the sports we love.

This Week’s Contributors

Neil Squires
Author and journalist, former chief sportswriter for the Express.

Neil McLeman
Broadcaster and journalist covering the Premier League, golf and tennis, former sportswriter for the Mirror.

Paul Mahoney
Award-winning journalist, former sportswriter for the Independent and Esquire.


After just five matches, Manchester City and Arsenal look like they may have separated from the pack. Is the Premier League title already a two-horse race?

Paul Mahoney: We all thought it was until Saturday, didn’t we? Brighton turning Arsenal over is fantastic. Like we said at the beginning of the season, this race is wide open. Even Manchester City on Sunday were basically playing pingpong with Sunderland. No one is making a statement that they’re hard to beat. I think that this season the league could be won with 80 points. You’re not going to need 95 points to win it this year.

Neil Squires: I don’t think it is a two-horse race. Over the course of the season, you’ve got to look at the heavyweights with the big squads that can last the pace. You’ve still got Liverpool in there, who are unbeaten. They haven’t looked fantastic, but they haven’t lost yet. Liverpool is just one win behind Arsenal, so it’s not all closed up.

Personally, I think Arsenal still look like the best side. But City have had a great start to the season. They’ve done everything that could be asked of them. Haaland’s banging the goals in, so they’re at the top. I still think Arsenal will win it, but I don’t see it as a two-horse race.

Neil McLeman: Put it this way—if you have to pick the two most likely teams to win it on the evidence of the first five games, you’d have to say Arsenal and Manchester City. I think it was good that Arsenal lost Saturday, because the way they played at the start of the season was worryingly good for everyone else. City as well—I think that was a huge win for them in the Manchester derby the previous weekend, for so many reasons. But I do think those two are the teams to beat this season.

I thought Chelsea would be there, too, but they’ve been pretty terrible. I still think they’ll come back. With a new manager, they’ve got improvement to make. But if you offered me a bet on the two teams to win the title, I’d definitely take Manchester City and Arsenal.

Who are the biggest surprises this season and which teams have the most reason to worry?

Neil McLeman: It’s been a really interesting start to the season. It’s been unpredictable, and I think that’s a good thing. Last season, in the top eight, we had Sunderland, Bournemouth and Brighton—they all qualified for Europe. Now the top eight after five games include Brighton, Brentford, Leeds, Hull and Everton. So it’s really been quite varied. Hull lost to Newcastle on Saturday, but for a promoted team to start so well, they’d be the big surprise so far this season, along with Leeds, who I’m glad to say have been doing really well.

The big worry for me is Manchester United. I watched the game Sunday and I thought they were pretty awful. I just don’t think they’ve kicked on from last season, and I think that’s a big issue. They were pedestrian, so lacking in imagination, so lacking in effort, that I think that’s a real worry for Manchester United.

Neil Squires: To echo Neil, Hull City have had an incredible start to the season—everyone had them down as nailed-on for relegation, but eighth place is an incredible start for them. Ipswich, another promoted team, is in 11th, so that’s pretty good, too.

But, for me, Leeds United have had a really strong start—they’ve only conceded three goals and they’ve built really strongly from the back. You can see real incremental improvement from last season, when they stayed up quite comfortably after being promoted. I don’t think they’ve necessarily got the squad to challenge for the title, but they could stick around this season. They look like a really solid team—hard to beat away from Elland Road as well as at home, where it’s a total fortress.

In terms of teams to worry about, Bournemouth haven’t won a game yet, and they’ve got European games to fit into the schedule this year. They haven’t got the biggest squad. Manager Marco Rosa is still settling in there, and he might be looking over his shoulder a little bit. If you’re on the sack-race watch in the Premier League, I think the Bournemouth situation looks a little bit uncomfortable.

Paul Mahoney: I’ve been pleasantly surprised by Brighton. If you had to guess who has the best goal difference so far, you’d think it would be Manchester City, but Brighton have got a better goal difference than them. They’ve had three clean sheets, and Pascal Groß has scored three goals already. That’s caught everyone unawares—I don’t think anyone saw Brighton doing that in the first five games. They look like a really solid team working together.

The team that’s surprising in a bad way, as Neil McLeman just mentioned, is Manchester United—they’re looking like they’re doing the same thing with manager Michael Carrick that they did with Ole Gunnar Solskjær. This afternoon, Gary Neville said that they played the worst 15 minutes in the second half that he’s seen Manchester United play since he was 5 years old. He’s obviously raving mad about the poor performances this season. He called them mannequins, and that’s what they look like—just walking around. So you wonder whether it’s [club co-owner] Jim Ratcliffe—he’s been saying some mad things about wanting to leave the UK because it’s not working very well, and the whole thing translates to Manchester United. He doesn’t seem to care about solving problems. Ratliffe is a high-profile shareholder in United. If he’s speaking like that, what does that tell you about what’s going on in the boardroom? That’s clearly translating into the changing room and onto the pitch, because United look an absolute mess.

Also worth mentioning—a quote resurfaced this week from David Moyes, who took over after Alex Ferguson. Back in 2013, Moyes said Manchester United must improve in a number of areas, including “passing, creating chances and defending.” Thirteen years later, the same stuff still applies. United are in a lot of trouble.

Neil McLeman: I agree that Brighton are the closest challengers to those top two. They’ve been outstanding with two results they've had in this last week: winning at Manchester United and beating Arsenal. Paul mentioned Pascal Groß—he is probably the best player in the Premier League so far. The way they’re coached, and the way they pressed Arsenal to death Saturday, it was an absolutely outstanding team display. From start to finish, they squeezed the life out of clearly the best team in England over the last 12 months. It will be really interesting to see how long they can keep this up physically. Brighton are a selling club. They sell players every year, yet they maintain this high standard

With all their talent, Chelsea should be a team that is competing for the title, but the results so far tell a different story. What’s holding Chelsea back?

Subscribe to keep reading

This content is free, but you must be subscribed to Box Score to continue reading.

I consent to receive newsletters via email. Terms of use and Privacy policy.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now