This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Welcome to The Debrief, Box Score’s freewheeling conversation about the sports we love.

This week, our Premier League experts talk about Manchester City’s troubles off the pitch and Manchester United’s troubles on it.

Contributors

Neil Squires
Author and journalist, former chief sportswriter for the Express.

Neil McLeman
Broadcaster and journalist covering the Premier League, golf and tennis, former sportswriter for the Mirror.

Paul Mahoney
Award-winning journalist, former sportswriter for the Independent and Esquire.


Manchester City is off to a 7-1 start despite playing under the shadow of a historic guilty ruling on breaching Premier League financial regulations and an impending and likely severe penalty. How do you see this playing out for City on the pitch and in the courtroom?

Neil McLeman: The first thing is this is the biggest story in the history of the Premier League, in my opinion. Absolutely extraordinary story. And it’s actually the easy part they’ve done now, as they’ve been found guilty by this inquiry. Now it’s finding what the punishment’s going to be. So this story is going to run and run. 

And the big danger for the Premier League is not only reputational damage to the Premier League going forward, which is a huge business at home and abroad, but it’s also what’s going to happen to this season. We just don’t know what the punishment’s going to be. What happens if Manchester City win the title this season and then they’ve deducted X amount of points? It’s going to be an extraordinary story.

The team has had this bunker mentality since this verdict. They lost at Aston Villa on Saturday, but I didn’t think that the performance was that bad, actually. Villa just has City’s number. They’ve beaten them four times on the run now. City is now level on points with Arsenal. So let’s see. We’ve got a title race on the pitch. But what happens off the pitch this season is going to be more important.

Neil Squires: I think Neil’s absolutely hit the nail on the head about the scale of this story. One thing worth noting is the job Manchester City manager Enzo Maresca has done in shutting all that out for the team. I mean, the noise is deafening, but he’s told them to make their noise on the pitch, and their response to it has been, I’d say, remarkable. It’s pretty much been business as usual. As Neil said, they played well enough at Villa. Yes, they probably deserved a point, but for an error by Donnarumma. Haaland’s still banging in the goals, leading scorer in the Premier League this season, nothing changes. And it’s quite remarkable given what’s gone on around the club. And in the background, must be the thought of what’s going to happen to them. Players and agents have got to be looking at different places for their players if the club is relegated down the leagues, which is quite a likely scenario.

If you look at an equivalence, there was a very small equivalent in the Premier League when Chelsea were docked £10 million and banned from a couple of transfer windows for breaching agent rules. But it’s nothing on the same scale as this. Chelsea complied with the investigation, whereas City have done everything to try and obstruct. And if their appeal fails, I think it’s quite likely that they’ll basically be out of the Premier League. They might even find themselves starting again at the bottom of League Two, which is just remarkable. And then the whole squad would go. So I’d say the fact that the players are just continuing on is a great credit to the manager.

Paul Mahoney: It can’t continue. Can you imagine an end of season where the Premier League has to award the trophy to City with fireworks going off in the background and having to sell that it’s a great win and another fantastic season? It would be a huge embarrassment for the league and the brand, if you want to call it that these days. They can’t get to May and have nothing done. It’ll just be awful. I think the Premier League are going to have to decide and release what the punishment is and then deal with what City do after that, because it will just make a complete farce of the season, which is already daft. 

I had the dubious pleasure of being at Anfield for City’s return to competitive football since the guilty verdict. It was the most bizarre football game I’ve ever been to. That bunker mentality that the City fans have been continuing of just creating a party atmosphere, pretending that everything’s okay. It works in the short term because, frankly, what are they expected to do? I think that any football club supporters’ group would be behaving the same, but it’s going to wear on them. And the same with the players. They’re getting vitriol from the opposition fans everywhere they go now. And whilst Elliot Anderson was laughing about it Saturday and Enzo Maresca’s been grinning and being cool, it’s going to wear on them, week after week after week of just being booed, and however strong they think they are, I think it’ll wear them down. 

But I don’t see any way around a massive points reduction and relegation, at the least. I mean, they ought to have penalties that keep them down for three or four seasons in the lower leagues, which will decimate the squad they’ve got now, and they’ll have to start again. But that’s the way it is.

Neil McLeman: That’s what I find one of the many fascinating aspects of this: what is an appropriate punishment? And it goes beyond sport. This has become a political and business decision. The first thing, Manchester City is owned by a foreign government, basically. It’s owned by Abu Dhabi. So there are political implications. There are already reports in the UK press about the Abu Dhabi government putting pressure on the UK government not to sanction them too much. Abu Dhabi has huge investments in the UK economy. And the Premier League is owned by the clubs. Do they want to get rid of Manchester City permanently effectively, or for the next five years or so? Do you want to not have Erling Haaland playing in the Premier League?

Subscribe to keep reading

This content is free, but you must be subscribed to Box Score to continue reading.

I consent to receive newsletters via email. Terms of use and Privacy policy.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now