Welcome to The Signal, Box Score's Wednesday newsletter. This week, we're looking at prediction markets like Polymarket and Kalshi to explain how they work, why these markets are disrupting established sports gambling players like FanDuel and DraftKings, and where this all is headed.
Three winters ago, I found myself at a holiday party packed with people from the sports gambling industry. I knew a handful of them from writing a book about the industry a few years earlier, back when this whole business was a couple of startups, a legal gray area and an ungodly amount of annoying TV advertising. (Some things never change.) By then, sports betting had exploded into a regulated industry, with Americans collectively wagering more each year than the entire economy of Morocco. More than a few of those founders, early VPs and engineers had gotten very, very rich.
The companies they worked for were now worth billions, but plenty of them clearly hadn’t shaken their inner Richard Hendricks, the startup paranoia that it could all vanish overnight. Which seemed odd. Having survived the regulatory gauntlet, a spate of scandals and brutal headlines, the behemoths DraftKings and FanDuel, in particular, seemed too big to fail.
I was curious what still kept them up at night. A Tim Donaghy-level betting scandal, I figured. Or one of those apocalyptic weekends when every favorite covers and the public cleans out the books (much like the past two weekends of the NFL season).
Instead, I kept hearing the same answer: prediction markets.
At the time, prediction markets were a niche curiosity, where people could put money on yes-or-no outcomes like elections, the weather, or the next James Bond. Polymarket wasn’t even legal in the US. The idea of prediction markets taking over the world was… a stretch.
Those partygoers should have put money on their hunch. While the sports gambling industry spent the past eight years legalizing sports betting one state at a time, prediction markets are making it legal everywhere at once, whether the states like it or not.
Today, every future event has a price on a prediction market platform. A ceasefire in the Ukraine–Russia war in December: 12 cents. Jensen Huang back as CEO of Nvidia by year’s end: 16 cents. The US government confirming aliens exist by the end of the year: 2 cents.
These are this morning’s prices on Polymarket, one of the now-legal platforms where yes-or-no questions get packaged as financial instruments. Put a dollar on the aliens, and if the little green men show up, you walk away with $50. Still a smarter bet than the Jets winning the Super Bowl.
But as far as the federal government is concerned, Kalshi and Polymarket aren’t sportsbooks, and what happens on them isn’t gambling. They’re registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) as financial exchanges, which is why they’re permitted to operate in states like Texas and California, where it’s still illegal to set money on fire on same-game parlays.
Prediction markets had a moment during the midterm elections, when the markets proved remarkably accurate as indicators of how the election would break in a Bluenami. In the week of the election, political markets did $1.4 billion in trading. That’s an astounding number—that is, until you look at the sports weekend after the election. Over a regular-season slate of college football and NFL games, prediction markets moved more than $14 billion. For all the buzz about the elections, one weekend of football drew 10 times as much money.

This is what the industry insiders saw coming in 2023. Prediction markets pitch themselves as a place where future events trade like stocks, regulated like oil and corn futures. The companies’ founders talk loftily of price discovery, revealed truths, and the wisdom of crowds.
Then you follow the money.


